Key groups to attend Afghan talks
UN-backed meeting of Afghan factions to be held Tuesday in Bonn
UN envoys continue talks in advance of Bonn meeting on Afghanistan
Q&A: What will Afghan talks produce?

Sunday, 25 November, 2001, 13:01 GMT

Key groups to attend Afghan talks
 
Exiled king Zahir Shah is seen as a rallying point
 
By the BBC's regional analyst Pam O'Toole

Last minute efforts are under way to finalise the guest list for a crucial conference on Afghanistan to be held in Bonn on Tuesday.

So far only four main groups are said to be attending - representatives of the Northern Alliance, which has won huge military victories in Afghanistan over recent weeks; representatives of the former king, and delegations from two organisations known as the Cyprus Group and the Peshawar group.

The Northern Alliance says its team will be headed by its interior minister Younis Qanooni.

He is a member of the dominant Jamiat Islami party, led by ousted president Burhanuddin Rabbani.

It is not clear if Mr Rabbani himself will attend.

Tension

Over recent days he has spoken scathingly about the Bonn meeting.

And there have been rumours of tensions between himself and other Northern Alliance leaders.

In the past, the Alliance's disparate parties have often only been united by their opposition to common enemies.

Its real commitment to power-sharing has yet to be tested.

The former king, Zahir Shah, is also sending a delegation representing a broad range of ethnic groups and political opinions.

The king himself is regarded as a potential rallying point for the nations and particularly for Afghanistan's substantial Pashtun community.

It lacks a single strong political leader following the collapse of the Teleban.

But he is likely to be only a figurehead in any interim administration.

The United States is keen to ensure some kind of role for him.

But despite his insistence that he has no ambitions to restore the monarch, Iran is still suspicious of the idea of him playing a prominent role.

The third delegation will be assembled by another pro- king figure, Pir Gailani.

He is the spiritual leader of a small religious party and was perhaps the most moderate member of the seven party mujaheddin government in 1992.

He is now perceived to be backed by Pakistan.

The final group - known as the Cyprus group - is thought to be close to Iran.

It is a collection of Afghan politicians and representatives of smaller mujaheddin groups who have met periodically over the past few years to discuss new ways of bringing peace to Afghanistan.

Their meetings have been attended by a broad spectrum of people - including the son-in-law of the radical Islamic mujaheddin leader Gulbuddin Hekmatyar.

UN-backed meeting of Afghan factions to be held Tuesday in Bonn

23 November - Logistical constraints will push a planned meeting of Afghan factions in Bonn back from Monday to Tuesday, a United Nations spokesman announced today.

"Getting people from all over the world to Bonn has its difficulties of course, and therefore we want to allow enough time for people to arrive," said Ahmad Fawzi, the spokesman for UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan's Special Representative for Afghanistan, Lakhdar Brahimi.

The one-day delay would also allow for consultations in advance of the formal session "so that we have time on the UN side to confer with the delegations, and for the delegations to confer amongst themselves before the official opening of the conference on Tuesday," Mr. Fawzi told reporters at a press briefing in New York.

The bulk of the UN delegation would arrive on Saturday, with Afghan delegations arriving in the days to follow, he noted. The meeting aimed to bring together parties from the Northern Alliance, the Rome Process, the Cyprus Process and the Peshawar Convention to talk about forming a broad-based multi-ethnic government.

"The measure of the success of this meeting will be if we can come up with a formula for a transitional administration for Afghanistan - that is what we are hoping they will agree to," said Mr. Fawzi.

Such a formula – involving all groups in Afghanistan, including women – would then be taken to Kabul for the beginning of a phased implementation. “This is the first step along a long road to establishing good governance in Afghanistan,” he said.

Mr. Fawzi also stressed that the conference would provide a forum for Afghans to determine their country’s future. The UN would be “facilitating” the event.

According to the spokesman, Afghan factions would be well-represented, including the country's major ethnic group - the Pashtuns, who formed the base of the Taliban. "At this stage we think we have good representation of the Afghan factions," he said. "I don't think it's realistic to expect the Taliban to be participating in this meeting; there is talk that at some future stage moderate elements of the Taliban could be included."

The gathering, formally called the UN Conference on Afghanistan, will be held in Petersberg in Konigswintwer near Bonn.

UN envoys continue talks in advance of Bonn meeting on Afghanistan


21 November - Secretary-General Kofi Annan's Deputy Special Representative for Afghanistan today completed a mission to Kabul, where he held talks with leading officials in advance of next week's meeting in Bonn of various Afghan factions.

Before returning to Islamabad today, Francesc Vendrell met with Berhanuddin Rabbani, President of the United Front. The Deputy Special Representative will leave over the weekend for Germany to attend Monday's meeting on the formation of a broad-based government in Afghanistan.

The Bonn gathering is being convened by Special Representative Lakhdar Brahimi, who has been continuing talks with officials in New York. His programme today included meetings with Norway's Deputy Foreign Minister, Vidar Helgesen, and Sadako Ogata, the Representative of the Japanese Prime Minister dealing with Afghanistan and a former UN High Commissioner for Refugees. Mr. Brahimi also met with Japan's Ambassador to the UN, Yukio Satoh.
 

Tuesday, 20 November, 2001, 18:17 GMT
Ahead of talks among of Afghanistan's ethnic groups in Germany on Monday, the BBC's Paul Reynolds looks at what might come of the historic conference on Afghanistan's political future.

What are the key things that the UN and the US-led coalition hope to achieve in these talks ?

The main aim of the conference (which might only last for one day) is to get the parties to make a declaration committing them to a broad-based government for Afghanistan, to be set up after a two-year interim administration.

This declaration would be followed up by detailed negotiations in the coming weeks.

The plan is for all major factions to be there, except the Taleban. The conference might prove to be the easy bit. The real work will come afterwards.

Are the views of neighbouring countries like Pakistan and Iran being taken into account? What about Russia?

The views of neighbouring countries will be taken into account but will not determine the outcome, nor will they be a specific part of the conference.

The UN special representative for Afghanistan, Lakhdar Brahimi, says there has to be a "home-grown" solution.

This means that Pakistan, though it opposes the Northern Alliance, will have to accept that the alliance is a major player and that Russia, which supports the alliance, knows that its allies do not have complete control.

As the force that controls the capital, Kabul, does the Northern Alliance hold all the cards?

The Northern Alliance holds major cards, but not all of them. It has possession of Kabul, but it does not have the allegiance of all the Afghan tribes, especially the Pashtun.

The alliance has said it is willing to share power. Its intentions will now be tested.

The alliance has the military might of the United States behind it and will not want to put that at risk - a powerful incentive for it to compromise.

Is the return to Kabul of the deposed former king of Afghanistan likely?

The former king, Zahir Shah, seems unlikely to play the major role foreseen for him at an earlier stage.

Indeed, the UN and Western governments are disappointed that he has not proved to be more of a rallying point.

But his approval of the process that is to be kicked off in the conference is seen as important.

He might return to Kabul at some stage but nothing is planned.

Will they try to agree on a UN peacekeeping force for Afghanistan?

A UN peacekeeping force could prove a real problem. Already, the Northern Alliance (or United Front, as it calls itself) has shown resistance to the widespread use of foreign forces (like the British).

It argues that there is peace in Kabul already and therefore there is no need for a peacekeeping force.

There is a chance of agreement on a force made up of countries with Muslim populations, such as Indonesia, Bangladesh and Turkey - though the Turkish military is secular.

But such a force could be a symbol rather than a power.

With so many ethnic factions in Afghanistan, how will they reach an agreement?

This is the big question and there are no easy answers.

The best that can be said is that the eyes of the world are on Afghanistan and that other countries in chaos (Germany and Japan after the second world war, for example) have emerged as stable societies.

Maybe this time, the Afghan people will sort themselves out. The worst case scenario is that what is now a civil war will continue and the country will be fragmented.

What happens next if there is no agreement at the talks?

The talks are likely to produce a declaration but that is only the start. The dots will have to be joined up in further discussions.

But if this fails, then the warlord solution comes into effect, with strong individuals controlling local sectors.

The war against Osama bin Laden and the Taleban, which were the reasons for the war in the first place, will go on in any case. It will not end until they are defeated.


The views expressed in the contributed papers are that of the writer (s) and are not necessarily shared by the Institute for Afghan  Studies (IAS). In addition the IAS can take no responsibility for the quality and content of contributed material and external links.  Please review our Privacy Statement.
www.institute-for-afghan-studies.org
To contact us, send us an email at: info@institute-for-afghan-studies.org
Copyright Protected 2001